This discussion was fascinating ... and I am very glad that Stuart and Darren invited me to be a part of this.
I had an issue a few weeks ago where a Community owner of a Lotus Connections Community deleted the forums widget - realised that deleting it - well actually meant it was gone.
In the user's defence, they wanted to make the forum read only and thought that removing it from the community would mean it would be retained elsewhere. My poor distraught user did actually say that the system warned that it was going to delete it - The user in question is not dumb, They are intelligent, switched on and web-savvy, yet still they managed to delete something that actually warned them it was going to be deleted.
My initial reaction was "how can anyone be so STUPID?" I huffed and puffed and once my initial mood of "muppet" had worn off I thought about it in more detail. Maybe for community widgets the error message needs to be more specific, users need to realise that deleting means not just from the community but GONE - this is not apparent it seems - some work may need to be done here.
The user in question called me in a panic once the widget had been deleted and realised that the information contained in said widget was not available outside of the community. I tried to play the "sorry - it's gone" card, but this was possibly the most important thing ever stored on the Connections environment - Consultation feedback about our Vice Chancellors vision for where the University is heading for the next 5 years,
I started taking a serious look into how I would get this information back - I thought it would be a chore .. but do-able, It wasn't as straight forward as I had hoped.
Communities are a fantastic thing inside connections - having a collection of people collaborating on a certain subject, or a bunch of like minded people just *shooting the breeze* getting ideas out and sharing knowledge. Many of the users here love the fact they can customise their own communities by adding removing and hiding widgets - fabulous for the users .. nightmare for the admins.
On the whole Disaster Recovery isn't an issue - we all have the multi-tier, multi-layed system covered with the DB, AppServer, WebServer, File system, OS covered.
Its the incremental one file, one widget, a wiki page which seems to be the biggest headache - heaven forbid you remove a whole community as that is a whole lot of hurt that you don't want to visit.
The single applications that sit outside connections are pretty hard to restore bits of as it is .. there is the DB to consider - tables for the actual application, things stored in the file system, dependancies, triggers or key to other DB's - which makes it pretty tough to work out exactly what you would need to restore at any given point in time - chances are something is going to be lost in a restore.
Communities brings a whole new level of complexity to the party - as well as the community application there are the 6 or so widgets to add as well leading to some very complex relationships between the DB tables in ways that will make your brain dribble out of your ears, as well as complex relationships to the file system. I personally haven't found any decent documentation on restoring sections of a community or a whole community.
The fact that connections relies so heavily on the database and it's ties to the file system I am really surprised that at least the DB relationships aren't documented.
After working with WebSphere Commerce (on as/400, iSeries) in my previous employer (IBM Premier Business Partner) we had much the same issues. WebSphere Commerce is the only other IBM product that I have come across in my 10 years of being involved with this stuff, which has such a heavy dependancy on it's DB relationships.
We spent about 5 years working with IBM to make the documentation better and assisting with beta programs, testing next versions of WCS and giving IBM all the feedback possible to help with making the product and documentation as great as possible.
One of the best things about the commerce documentation was the reference section - particularly the Database reference section. Each table listed with a description of the table and information on each field there is also index and constraint information and information on which tables and constraints reference the table you are looking at (see images at the end of the post)
By all means just having information about the DB is not going to be enough, but it is a start. Connections is such a complicated piece of software - and as it improves and is easier to customise - it's going to get more complicated. BUT Connections is sold as an enterprise ready application and for it to be totally successful it needs to have enterprise ready documentation on administering the back up and recovery of features and individual files, folders and pages.
Whether this is handled by "soft delete", admin commands, or a 3rd party application - it needs to be looked at as a matter of urgency.
In the end to allow the user to get access to the information deleted it was easier to restore the entire DB to new DB instance, build a stand-alone Connections server to point to the DB, do a small amount of DB manipulating and the user copied the forum questions and responses off in PDF format and has since uploaded them back to the files sections of their community. All in all that took approximately 2 days - just to retrieve 28 pages of information - a pain, a lot of hassle, but that appeared to be the fastest way at the time.
I would be more than happy to discuss my experiences with attempting to restore, and experiences around similar issues seen in Commerce if it will help in anyway. I am sure there are other members of the Connections community that would be happy to assist too. Connections is a fantastic product, lets make it better but helping us poor admins out :)
Do you monitor your Connections environment?
Tue, Sep 23rd 2014 8:11a Sharon Bellamy After being to a few user groups lately and seeing all the great monitoring tools for Domino I am interested in what people use to monitor connections.
The WebSphere piece of connections can put a lot of people off and I am wondering if something was available would you use it?
If you do monitor, what do you use
If something was available with a *dashboard* would you use it?
What features would you like in a monitoring app
Would you be interested in something bundled in Nagios etc
I have creat [read] Keywords: connections
MWLUG here I come
Fri, Aug 22nd 2014 4:10p Sharon Bellamy I have been a bit quiet on the blog lately. I have been a little busy both work wise and home wise what with making costumes and building armour (more of that in another post) but this weekend I fly out to my very first MWLUG.
I am really looking forward to it after hearing so many great things about it. I will be speaking on the thursday morning, but am arriving on sunday the 24th so will get to spend a few days seeing the sites and working from the hotel room.
If you are going to be there I a [read] Keywords:
dandering for dosh -the story so far
Wed, Jun 4th 2014 6:14a Sharon Bellamy We are just about to start dandering for dosh day 3 & so far despite a few injuries (mainly to me), some very rough terrain and much scorching of the sun – we all appear to be enjoying it
Day 2 mostly involved us being mountain goats, although we did get an hour on the beach on the fabulous Warren & kitty ‘ s inflatable sofas.
Loving the dander so far – more news and pictures to follow ;).
The post dandering for dosh -the story so far appeared first on Social Shaz [read] Keywords:
Registration for ICONUK now open
Thu, May 1st 2014 6:12a Sharon Bellamy Registration for Icon UK is now open
Head over to the registration page and sign up early as placed are limited.
If you would like to speak please submit your abstracts before 30th June. There are four tracks this year, Management/Strategy, Development, Admin and Open Source. If you are interested in sponsoring please email firstname.lastname@example.org.
I am all resisted and really looking forward to the event – see you there
The post Registration for ICONUK now open appeared first on Social S [read] Keywords: admin
Please sponsor us Dandering for Dosh
Fri, Apr 25th 2014 6:12a Sharon Bellamy The Cube Soft team (Nathan and I) have joined with some other fantastic members of the ICS (Lotus) Community and are joining this years Dander for Dosh.
10 Geeks, 100 Miles, 5 days – what could possibly go wrong
In previous years a group of community members have raised money for worthy causes with a sponsored walk across some of the British Isles most beautiful country side.
This years walk is the Lleyn Peninsula Coastal Path (Edge of Wales Walk) 85 miles in five days, and as our coordinato [read] Keywords: lotus
Fun and games with Commuity wigets
Thu, Apr 24th 2014 6:11a Sharon Bellamy Last night we managed to close a PMR that had been open for a few weeks on a strange issue with Community Widgets.
After remapping the connections admin user everything worked exactly as expected except for 2 tiny issues – Adding the blogs and surveys widgets inside a community thew a nasty error.
Thanks to Justin Cornell in IBM support we managed to get to the bottom of the issue by remapping the widgets admin user even though it was mapped correctly.
Jump over to the Cube Soft Blog - Fu [read] Keywords: admin
Help shape connections search
Thu, Apr 10th 2014 1:11p Sharon Bellamy If you are interested in helping IBM shape the search application inside Connections there is a survey that you can participate in.
This is a short survey to better understand attitudes and behaviours around search and how users – well – use it
You can find the search survey here
Fill it in and you will make a Connections product manager very happy [read] Keywords: connections
Odd issue with Connections Mail
Wed, Apr 2nd 2014 6:10a Sharon Bellamy I have been looking to implement Connections mail for a while for one of my customers, after finally sorting out some SSO issues we had been seeing I was ready to deploy into their DEV/TEST environment. No problem I thought – Connections mail is a very simple install a couple of config files and a quick wsadmin command to get the help to work.
Once I had deployed I was seeing the strangest issues -
Contact your system administrator:
Missing element with class=”os-site-mail-notify [read] Keywords: connections
Speaking at Engage
Fri, Feb 14th 2014 11:10a Sharon Bellamy I will be speaking at Engage by BLUG in March – a big thank you to Theo and the team for the opportunity
On Monday the 17th of March I will be Christoph Stoettener’s assistant again in delivering – Adm04. Practical Solutions for Connections Administrators – Tips and Scripts for Your Daily Business – 14:45 – 15:30, room: B
On Tuesday the 18th of March I will be speaking with my friend and college Mr Tim Clark – Adm08. Collaboration Stack – Lessons L [read] Keywords: collaboration
so I DID make it to Connect
Tue, Feb 4th 2014 3:10p Sharon Bellamy So thanks to some very good fortune and help from an old and awesome friend I was able to make the Connect conference in Orlando last week.
I will post my full round up later in the week – but the highlights
SPEAKING for the first time with my good friend Christoph Stoettner I am not ashamed to say I was extremely nervous about speaking at Connect for the first time, but if I have the opportunity to do so again I will grab it with both hands
The flow for the first two days wit [read] Keywords: connections